Sources and method
Where every number comes from
Every number in the HERD Atlas and in a Benchmark Brief traces to one of two federal sources. Each brief repeats this page for the years it uses.
1. NCSES HERD Survey
The Higher Education Research and Development (HERD) Survey of the National Center for Science and Engineering Statistics (NCSES), part of the National Science Foundation, counts research and development spending at U.S. colleges and universities every fiscal year. We use the public-use files of the standard form, which report spending by field of research and by source of funds, including six federal agencies. Schools with under $1 million in R&D fill in a short form without that detail and are not ranked.
- Units: thousands of current dollars, not adjusted for inflation.
- Years: FY2016 to FY2024 today. NCSES lists 24 November 2026 as the next release, with FY2025; briefs ordered after it use the new year.
- Estimates: NCSES fills some missing items with estimates (1.2% of FY2024 dollars nationally). We use them as published.
- Source: ncses.nsf.gov.
2. IPEDS Completions
Research doctorates come from the Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS) of the National Center for Education Statistics: doctor’s degrees of the research/scholarship type, first major, all fields (award level 17, the grand-total row). Academic years run July to June; the latest year can be provisional.
- Source: nces.ed.gov/ipeds.
3. How we compute
- Totals add every field and source of funds.
- Federal spending adds the six named agencies (USDA, DOD, DOE, HHS, NASA, NSF) and "other federal".
- Ranks count schools that filed the standard form with spending above zero in that year; ties share a rank.
- Three-year averages are plain averages of the three latest years.
- Peer groups: the schools you name, plus built-in groups: your state, HBCU and high-Hispanic-enrollment (NCSES flags), AAU members and athletic conferences (as listed in our files, by NCSES institution ID).
- The Carnegie gap compares spending and research doctorates with the thresholds the Carnegie Classifications published for their 2025 research designations: $50 million and 70 doctorates for R1, $5 million and 20 doctorates for R2. The thresholds are Carnegie’s; the counts are ours, from the data above. Carnegie makes the classification, not us.
4. What the data cannot tell you
Schools report their own figures, and practices differ. Reporting units sometimes merge or split, so a jump between years can reflect reporting rather than research. Dollars are current dollars, so part of any growth is inflation.
DC2 Analytics is independent and not affiliated with NSF, NCSES, the U.S. Department of Education or the Carnegie Classifications.